Is Irrational Exuberance Giving Way to Rational Behavior

I recently enjoyed a conversation with a friend who is about to list their residence in one of Denver’s most affluent neighborhoods (of note I was NOT in the competition for the listing). He mentioned what they plan to list the home at. I asked if they were planning to use the broker whom they have a personal relationship with and they advised no as what they wish to list the home at, the broker would not take the listing feeling the asking price was overly aggressive. Another broker has since been retained to market and sell the home.

Full disclosure, the home is spectacular from a conservative design perspective including solid pre-war construction, beautiful curb appeal, and a park-like oversized lot professionally landscaped and so forth. Of course there are some minor deficiencies yet nothing insurmountable. However when I was advised of the asking price my immediate reaction based on my experience in the present market was “Good Luck”.

I personally went through a similar situation with clients in 2011. Due to a change in employment status and other factors including owning the largest home on the block purchased at an inflated 2006 price, a challenging layout  and across the alley from a primary school  the sellers and this home had multiple challenges. At the Listing Presentation with a peer broker in attendance we advised the seller the asking price should be between $710,000-$720,000. The seller requested I place the house on the market for $839,000 (their purchase price was over $800K plus interior upgrades leading to a cost-basis in excess of $840,000). As a friend first and broker second (and I have since learned my lesson) I did as requested. After one month, multiple open-houses and two formal showings the sellers agreed to lower the price. The new asking $739,000, still above what was advised the prior month. Fifty yes 50 showings later and 9 months on the market not one offer! We decided to part ways. The seller hired another broker, within one week did a price reduction and subsequently sold the residence for $715,000.

It took the seller ten(10) months to sell for $715,000 which I had advised, from day one AND at $4,000/month mortgage, do the math, $40,000 before interest deduction, not exactly the most brilliant strategy.

Thus based on the above examples and seeing signs of a slowing market and for my own edification I decided to look at market activity both present and looking back at Sold Activity over the past 6 months.

Let’s start with Country Club (the borders are from Downing St. to west-side of University Blvd, 1st Avenue to 6th Avenue).

Sales Activity over the last 6 Months Country Club Neighborhood of Denver:

  • # Of homes sold: 7
  • Avg. Finished SF: 3,510 SF
  • Avg. Total SF: 4,482 SF
  • Average Sold PSF Finished: $568.38
  • Average Sold PSF Total: $445.01
  • Average Days on Market: 24 Days

On the Market at Present:

  •  # Of homes on the market: 8
  • Avg. Finished SF: 3,186 SF
  • Avg. Total SF: 4,419 SF
  • Average Sold PSF Finished: $557.31
  • Average Sold PSF Total: $424.36
  • Average Days on Market: 68 Days and counting

Based on size the differences between the Sold’s and on market is marginal and same concerning the Price per Square Foot however what is telling is Days on Market (DOM). The Sold’s over the last 6 months on average sold in 24 days. Yet those on the market today is average 68 days and counting. The difference, over one month, almost a month and a half.

I admit one could argue the homes on the market at present may have challenges from location to upkeep however as asking prices based on a Per Square Foot basis stayed relatively the same, the issue is the longer on market time. Number of days on market has more than doubled. Yes there are seasonal factors however many pundits argue the selling season is now year round.

My personal view is market demand is softening and asking prices are yet to adjust to the new market realities.

Of note, Country Club is a small, insular neighborhood with limited inventory and limited turnover. Thus I also looked at Cherry Creek North (1st Avenue to 6th Avenue, University Blvd to Colorado Blvd) to provide a more balanced view, granted however balanced one of the metro’ area’s most affluent neighborhoods can be. However with the diverse housing stock and density, a clearer picture may emerge.

Sales Activity over the last 6 Months Cherry Creek North Neighborhood of Denver:

  •  # Of homes sold: 53
  • Avg. Finished SF: 2,396 SF
  • Avg. Total SF: 3,335 SF
  • Average Sold PSF Finished: $436.10
  • Average Sold PSF Total: $332.28
  • Average Days on Market: 53 Days

On the Market at Present:

  •  # Of homes on the market: 94
  • Avg. Finished SF: 2,393 SF
  • Avg. Total SF: 3,416 SF
  • Average Sold PSF Finished: $595.36
  • Average Sold PSF Total: $412.07
  • Average Days on Market: 95 Days and counting

Again as with Country Club based on size the differences between the Sold’s and on market is marginal and same concerning the Price per Square Foot however what is telling again is Days on Market (DOM). The Sold’s over the last 6 months on average sold in 53 days. Yet those on the market today is average 95 days and counting. As with Country Club the difference is almost a month and a half.

Conclusion: In both neighborhoods asking and closed prices have stayed somewhat status quo. However in a hot housing market the number of days on market is telling. Granted one could use the seasonal differential argument. Maybe; however in both neighborhoods we are seeing the Days of Market mirror each other i.e. almost a month and a half difference.

I may be incorrect and I admit when I am however I believe the market is definitely showing signs of slowing based on Days on Market coupled with levels of inventory. Yes the two markets are considered luxury markets yet what happens at the upper-end of the market historically trickles down to other market segments. What will be interesting is when we will begin witnessing price adjustments.

It seems the pinnacle of the market may have been 6-12 months prior and the market is now possibly taking a well-deserved breather or maybe showing signs of a changing business cycle.

Considering interest rates have remained stable; actually still close to historic lows, the stock market continues to flirt with record highs and the recent issues with N. Korea are too recent to influence the housing market.

I believe the optimists will advise it is a natural seasonal shift, me being the conservative pessimist would advise, hang tight if you can it may be a bumpy ride ahead.

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

April 2017 Statistics Are in the Books

While the news on the housing front continues to paint a rosy picture as we continue to be in a sellers market; statistically we may be entering a phase of normalicy concerning market conditions. While prices remain elevated and there is continued concern that average metro Denver incomes cannot keep up with the inflated housing market we are seeing signs of slowdowns concerning price appreciation and possibly an uptick in inventory coming to market.

Personally I enjoy looking at statistics. When combined with historical personal perspective i.e. lived through it there are insights and trends one may be able to extrapolate.

I was reviewing April 2017 market conditions:

In April 2017, there were 5,361 Active Listings in the metro area.

(Of note, the historical average # of listings in April is 15,710 based on statistics gathered between 1985 and 2016 also related usually the start of the Spring sales season).

Thus our average # of listings continues to be constrained especially when considering the increase of housing stock which has come on-line since the end of the great recession coupled with our population increase

Concerning sales prices:

The year-to-date average sales prices in April 2016 increased 6.05%.

In April 2015 that same statistic was 9.53%.

In April 2014 that same statistic was 12.9% (of note coming out of the recession).

Thus we are witnessing a slowdown in price appreciation (a good thing), slight increase in inventory (a good thing) and overall a potential plateau in the market.

Yes sales prices are stabilizing and getting closer to matching inflation and inventory is beginning to loosen HOWEVER couple this with the stock market at record highs, unemployment at record lows and no appreciable inflation or major interest rate hikes; we may be seeing signs of a housing slowdown in the metro area.

On the luxury side of the market while there have been some blockbuster sales of late, homes priced at $1M and over seem to be languishing on the market for longer periods coupled with price reductions. Granted some inventory came on market overpriced to start however price reductions are happening sooner and price cuts is more severe.

In my local Cherry Creek neighborhood which I admit is far from a barometer for the metro area the inventory of listings seems to be increasing and sales transactions are taking longer to close and usually after a price correction. Granted there has been a uptick in inventory south of 1st Avenue and much of the for sale inventory north of 1st Ave is east of Steele St. which some buyers consider less desirable yet the number of active listings continues to increase. As of this writing there were 41 active listings ranging from $215,000 to over $10M (of note both the lowest and highest price listings are condominiums).

Having been in the real estate brokerage business for a few decades now I am used to witnessing Metro Denver go through 5-7 year cycles concerning increased demand and then stability. While I do not believe we are in for a major correction, I do believe we will continue to see additional inventory come on-line and price appreciation slow to the inflation rate or a few ticks above which is the historic norm.

In the luxury market, which I track, I would be a little more concerned regarding price stability.

In the starter and move-up market baring a serious interest rate hike I am not concerned as demand will continue to outstrip supply. I would be hesitant concerning starter inventory in the exurbs as those markets are dependent on low fuel prices.

As I am advising clients at present:

Sellers: Consider putting on the market now as its low inventory and attractive interest rates.

Buyers: While rates are low, a good opportunity to lock in a fixed mortgage HOWEVER should consider waiting a few months to a year or two as inventory will continue to increase and while interest rates may tick up prices usually do the inverse.

Renters: Rents seem to be stabilizing and with the introduction of additional luxury inventory do not be surprised to see landlord concessions. Thus if in a rental consider resigning for another 6 months with an escape clause and if looking to rent, shop around and look for incentives to bring your net effective rent down.